Being part of the Government has its pluses and the minuses. Very often I wonder as why we in the Government are largely unable to meet the aspirations that people have from us. What I hate most about my profession is being referred to as Babus!! I remember how I used to revolt when my grandmother used to call me 'Babu' rather than my nickname 'Bobby' during my annual summer visits to my village in Azamgarh, UP. Today when the media refers to Government officers (IAS) as Babus, I feel miserable. Atleast grandma's Babu was with love and affection. Media and people by large call us Babus with contempt and ridicule. May be they are justified and rightly so. There are lots of expectations from us and do we actually do justice to what people expect or what is just and fair!!
Very often I feel, we dont and we are unable to. We do have our reasons for the same. Our favorite blame guy is who else, the politician. In 99% of the cases it is true that we do take irrational and illogical decisions on account of politicians. We do explain the wrongs to the politicians and in most cases we are over ruled. Why do the politicians over rule us. Privately most of them agree to our views but they have compulsions for what they do. What are these compulsions and why do they do all that they do.
One prime reason is money. Yes money. Unfortunately Democracy is a luxury and someone has to foot the bill for this luxury. Our democratic processes of elections are pretty expensive. It is common knowledge that anyone contesting Assembly or Parliament Elections has to spend a few crores to be anywhere near an outside chance to win elections. There might be a few exceptions but more than 95% of elections are won by people who spend crores. No one joins politics these days out of love for the nation or for a sense of service and dedication to the society. Those days ended with the end of the British rule when professionals like Gandhi, Nehru, Bose et al quit lucrative careers to join politics. Today people who dont get into Engineering, Medicine, Law, Civil Services, Teaching or any decent profession join politics. Having a criminal background can mean a fast track growth in this profession. Then they spend millions in contesting elections which are rather unpredictable. Huge investments can go awry. Even if one wins the election, one does not know if one will end up in the ruling party. Even if one is on the right side of the fence, not every one becomes a minister. If one becomes a minister, it is not sure if one will be able to get a portfolio that is regraded lucrative. Given the low probabilty of success in this field, those who get an opportunity want to make the most of it - recover their investments, make provisions for future elections and most of all find jobs or contracts for their thousand odd workers - who have families to feed and lives to live. In many ways they are forced to be corrupt and take illogical and irrational decisions. The bureacrats are supposed to check this. But for their own weaknesses and greed, they play along with the politicos and we get the government that we have. Corrupt and Non Performing!!
What then. Whats the solution. One can be State funding of elections and strict laws that check the criminal elements joining politics. This will create a situation when even professionals and well meaning people without money or muscle can think of joining the political profession. People do want clean men but we hardly give them a choice. Once such well meaning people join the Government, bureacrats will also fall in line as they will not have any excuses or alibis for their own acts of commission and omission.
We do need this. Lets think over and do this. It is definitely better than Babu Bashing!!!!
5 comments:
State funding of elections is something that I have been reading since ages. There are also numerous other such brilliant proposals. But they never see the light of day because of the inherent conflict of interest. Why would Netas shoot themselves in their feet? What's your take on this that since the law makers are the law breakers, there is no way out of this paradox.
best,
Vivek
True to an extent. But most Netas also agree that they are caught in this vicious circle and somehow we have to ensure that we come out of this. One solution is the PIL route, which has helped us take many important decisions with the help of the Courts. Or even the Election Commission can ensure that we incorporate such measures. Until and unless we limit the role of money and criminals in our polity, we will remian stuck in the logjam we are in.
I simply loved the words 'corrupt and non performing.' But then politics is a vicious circle due to all the money involved, not only in our state but everywhere in India I guess. I'm only waiting for the day when our State leader will be chosen through voting aka US presidential election type. How many will be able to stand up and speak like them with wisdom and knowledge ? That time mugging up all our so called 'speeches of the etc etc' will not help na ?
I liked the analysis of your problem. We need to start looking at the solutions for this problem as well. I guess beurocrats are called Babu's primarily to give respect to the profession. As this profession used to attract the brightest mind in the country. I would feel that today this has lost some amount of respect as they also bow in line with the politicians who are looking for short term gain as you have rightly pointed out. Why can't Babu's take firm stand for right things. I am sure some of you have shown the courage and done it in the past. Our constitution is quite comprehesive and designed for balancing Indian Beurocrats and Indian Politician.....
Dear Abhishek,
It is a very nice write up and fully agree with you that the conceptualisation of politics as a selfless service to society is flawed and prone to corruption. The concept of political leadership in india is a recent concept. The cohesiveness observed during our freedom struggle cannot be replicated in these times. According to me politics is a full time profession and there is lot of money spent even during non election times. I fail to understand why would people spend so much of money doing public rallies and not expect any return out of it.There should be some institutionalization of politics and I think that would be a good begining.
Regards,
Rahul Pandey
Post a Comment